Best Matchmakers in NYC (2026): Pros, Cons, and Options

There is no city more perfectly made for matchmaking than New York City. Time is valuable, standards are high, and the in-person options for finding love are…well…overplayed. 

And, yes, the dating scene here is challenging — it’s not just you. The NY Post wrote an article a few years back calling it a ‘cutthroat dating scene’ with ‘tales of misery’. 

But don’t worry; it’s not all doom and gloom just because the in-person options aren’t great. For many in the city, they turn to one of two options — dating apps or hiring a matchmaker. 

While NYC dating apps may be a good fit for some, the reality is that when your time is limited and you’re serious about finding a quality partner, enlisting the help of a trained professional is the only option that makes sense.

But where do you start? As we’ve been in the matchmaking business for over 15 years now, we wanted to share some helpful insight to help you find the best NYC matchmaker for you.

The hands-down best option is Three Day Rule. Here’s why.

When you want to work with the best matchmaking service in NYC that offers superior service at a fair price, there’s no better option than Three Day Rule. Our team has been proudly serving clients for over 15 years with countless success stories and happy couples. 

Why Three Day Rule? Here are a few important reasons. One, we understand what matters most to New Yorkers. You want quality, you want authenticity, and you don’t want your time wasted when it comes to finding love. We get that, and we deliver.

Two, we know that when you hire a professional matchmaker, you’re looking for someone willing to take the time to get to know you and respect your unique wants and needs. You don’t want a big-box solution that sends you matches who don’t align with what you’re looking for. You want a matchmaking partner that gets you.

Ultimately, New Yorkers understand better than anyone the importance of hiring the right people. And when it comes to finding love, you don’t want a second-rate option that isn’t ready to support you in the way you deserve.

For New Yorkers like you, there’s a reason Three Day Rule is the leader. If you’re ready to learn more, you have two options. One, use the link below to schedule your complementary introductory call with a member of our team. It’s an incredible, no pressure opportunity to ask the questions you need to determine if it’s a good fit. This is the best next step you can take today.

Or, if you’d prefer to read a bit more about Three Day Rule first, you can always check out what reviews of Three Day Rule are saying. 

Are there other NYC matchmaking options?

Yes, there are other matchmakers in NYC, both local and national brands. How many? Here are two data points.

First, according to Yelp, there are around 130 businesses in NYC that classify themselves as matchmakers. 

Now, this number is a bit inflated as many of the businesses listed on this list make other types of matches (outside of dating) and many appear to be out of business.

The second data point to look at is the NYC Divisions of Corporations filings for matchmaking services. A search for companies with “matchmaking” in the name in New York returns 53 results. 

Much like with Yelp, many of these businesses do other types of matchmaking (very few are dating related) and several are marked as inactive with the state. A search for a similar keyword like “matchmaker” yields 68 results with many of them being for non-dating-related companies.

What this means to you

The takeaway here is that there are other options for NYC matchmaking services, but many are inactive, have too small of a presence, or don’t offer an intimate and approachable enough experience like you’ll get with Three Day rule.